diff --git a/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/chat/Chat.java b/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/chat/Chat.java
index 0266d007d..c58c83881 100644
--- a/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/chat/Chat.java
+++ b/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/chat/Chat.java
@@ -821,7 +821,7 @@ public class Chat extends MiniPlugin
 
 		if (channel.isModerated())
 		{
-			event.getRecipients().removeIf(player -> !preferences.isActive(Preference.SHOW_CHAT));
+			event.getRecipients().removeIf(recipient -> !_preferencesManager.get(recipient).isActive(Preference.SHOW_CHAT));
 		}
 
 		if (customEvent.isFiltered())