diff --git a/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/report/data/ReportRepository.java b/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/report/data/ReportRepository.java
index 263f8e7d6..57f553921 100644
--- a/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/report/data/ReportRepository.java
+++ b/Plugins/Mineplex.Core/src/mineplex/core/report/data/ReportRepository.java
@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ public class ReportRepository
 	private static final String SET_REPORT_MESSAGE = "REPLACE INTO reportReasons (reportId, reporterId, reason, `server`, weight, `time`)" +
 			"  VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?);";
 
-	private static final String SET_REPORT_HANDLER = "REPLACE INTO reportHandlers (reportId, handlerId)" +
+	private static final String INSERT_REPORT_HANDLER = "INSERT IGNORE INTO reportHandlers (reportId, handlerId)" +
 			"  VALUES (?, ?);";
 
 	private static final String SET_REPORT_RESULT = "REPLACE INTO reportResults (reportId, resultId, reason, closedTime)" +
@@ -637,7 +637,7 @@ public class ReportRepository
 				Optional<Integer> handlerIdOptional = report.getHandlerId();
 				if (handlerIdOptional.isPresent())
 				{
-					PreparedStatement setReportHandlerStatement = connection.prepareStatement(SET_REPORT_HANDLER);
+					PreparedStatement setReportHandlerStatement = connection.prepareStatement(INSERT_REPORT_HANDLER);
 					setReportHandlerStatement.setLong(1, reportId); // report id
 					setReportHandlerStatement.setInt(2, handlerIdOptional.get()); // handler id
 					setReportHandlerStatement.execute();